The original Child’s Play (1988) is a classic in the killer doll genre, introducing audiences to the now-iconic Chucky. Directed by Tom Holland, the film perfectly blends supernatural horror with dark humour, creating a slasher film that stands out from the rest. The story follows young Andy, who receives a seemingly innocent Good Guy doll, only to discover that it’s possessed by the soul of serial killer Charles Lee Ray. What makes the original work so well is its eerie atmosphere, clever tension-building, and Brad Dourif’s unforgettable voice performance as Chucky. The practical effects are impressive for their time, making Chucky’s movements genuinely unsettling. The film plays on the fear of childhood innocence being corrupted, and it does so in a way that is both creepy and entertaining.
In 2019, Child’s Play was remade with a modern twist, replacing the supernatural element with artificial intelligence. This time, Chucky isn’t possessed by a murderer—he’s an AI-powered toy whose safety protocols have been disabled, leading him to develop an obsessive attachment to Andy. While this update makes sense in today’s tech-driven world, it removes much of what made Chucky so terrifying in the first place. Instead of a calculating, evil personality, this version of Chucky is more of a misguided machine learning how to kill. Mark Hamill provides a solid voice performance, giving Chucky a more tragic and robotic tone, but it lacks the sinister charm of Dourif’s original portrayal.
Visually, the remake is well-made, and there are some creative kills, but it struggles to match the original’s eerie tension and dark humour. It feels more like a sci-fi horror film rather than a slasher, and while it has its moments, it doesn’t have the same impact. The original Child’s Play is a horror staple that spawned a long-running franchise for a reason—it had personality, tension, and an iconic villain. The remake is an interesting reinterpretation, but it ultimately lacks the same energy and memorability.
Winner: Child’s Play (1988)
About The Author
